If you snooze, you will lose your bees!

By Rod Bourke
NSW Bee Biosecurity Officer

In my role as an NSW Bee Biosecurity Officer, I talk with many beekeepers every week. For the most part these conversations have always been productive and enjoyable and with the odd exception, it is great to help them with advice on how to better manage their bees. However, in the last 2 years or so a lot more calls are coming in from beekeepers who have just lost their bee hives and are not 100% certain why.

When asked what has happened to their hives, the most common initial response has been “because my bees were poisoned” or “all of my bees swarmed”. Whenever one of the BBO team hears that from a beekeeper (or if we see a slide result that was sent to our lab being negative for brood disease) we are now generally considering that varroa may be implicated in the case.

Having a few (or even a few hundred) dead bees around the entrance of a beehive is very common and should not really be all that concerning, as in any normal strength colony, many, many hundreds of bees may die every single day during the season. Generally, most bees die out in the field whilst foraging away from home and are never seen by the beekeeper, but even if just 20-30 old ones died overnight and were pushed out the front entrance that is 150-200 bees a week being dropped out there. If ants, birds and other things don’t remove those bees, then the numbers build up pretty quickly and may appear to be alarming (but mostly they are not).

If, on the other hand there are thousands upon thousands of unwell/dead bees within the hive (often completely filling spaces between each brood comb) and crawling around and twitching at the front of the hive. then it could be from poisoning. If that is the case, then you should contact the NSW Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) as they are the lead agency that handles bee poisoning events. The EPA can allocate a case officer to investigate and advise how samples can be collected so that they can be sent off to a laboratory for sampling. Please note, generally the beekeeper pays for the lab testing, so make sure you are certain that it is poisoning before outlaying all that money to test for the potential chemical responsible.

Varroa In Drones Cropped 600

Many beekeepers have blamed poisoning as the reason why their hive died, but when the situation is investigated more closely. the colony actually had extremely high, unmanaged varroa mite numbers. This becomes abundantly clear when many dead mites are observed on the bottom board (mites that died of old age-because they had been living and reproducing in the hive for a very long time!) or are washed off dead or remaining live bees, or when uncapping any remaining unspoiled brood. Whenever looking for mites make sure to use your glasses, magnifying glass or zoom on your phone camera if needed, as they are quite small and sometimes it can be very hard to see the mites.

The bees weren’t poisoned, the astronomical mite numbers were the real cause of the colony starting to lose its health (if we were bees then imagine something the size of a mud crab feeding on your liver), and once that damage intensified, the colony was unable to remain strong and literally just collapsed and died. Bees are an amazing “super colony”, but even they can only tolerate so much before they will fail.

And when I’m told that all the bees swarmed first up, in most of NSW, bees don’t readily swarm over winter (especially from a weak hive), and even if they did then only half the bees would take off! What really happened was that all of your bees that were still healthy enough to fly have absconded! The conditions within the hive had become so intolerable that instead of remaining in their lifelong home, the colony preferred to take a huge risk of escaping that hell hole and leaving everything behind (including brood and honey) to take their chances elsewhere. Traditionally the main reasons why a colony would abscond were from Small Hive Beetle (SHB) overrunning the hive and sliming it or a heavy infection of American Foulbrood. More recently and now more commonly, colonies are absconding because of very high varroa numbers.

Absconding colonies are often loaded up with many of our endemic viruses (varroa spread some of these), nosema and brood disease, plus they still have mites, so often absconding colonies don’t seem to thrive and will need a lot of additional support to get going again. Colonies (absconding and swarms) that go out into the wild become a SHB breeding opportunity, or if they do survive long enough to become strong then they will eventually become a mite bomb, weaken, creating a robbing opportunity for other colonies and then a SHB breeding event. Prevent colonies leaving your hives at all costs!

The reasons why the hives have been dying comes straight back to the beekeeper not managing their varroa, which is sometimes hard for the beekeeper on the other end of the line to hear and accept (human nature, looking for something else to blame rather than themselves). Accepting that you have a problem is the first step in working out how to fix it, as is then identifying and learning from your mistakes. Doing both these things will quickly enable you to become a better beekeeper (with varroa), as the extra layer of complexity managing varroa is new, but not excessively onerous work to undertake.

Managing varroa in your beehive is also much, much cheaper than managing ticks and fleas on your household pets, yet even with your bees also generating an income stream (honey) many beekeepers seem reluctant to spending a little bit of that production to keep their bees healthy (low mite count) and very importantly still alive. Once your bees die you won’t make any more honey from them (plus you have a mess to clean up), but when you manage them properly, they will continue being a highly productive unit that is worth their weight in liquid gold. Dogs and cats literally cannot compete with how great bees are at paying their own way and also feeding themselves.

Weak Cropped 600

In many populous parts of NSW varroa has been present for at least the last 18 months-2 years (or longer), so if beekeepers in those areas tell me that they don’t have varroa yet (I still hear that every week, but a visit to the heat map normally shows high mite detections) then generally I know straight away that they are not actually looking. If you are not actively looking, then you are also not managing varroa either!

If you want to keep bees (which is still very achievable now that varroa is here), then please aim to keep them properly. Monitor for varroa frequently, using the most quick and accurate monitoring tool which is an alcohol wash. Forget about using a sugar shake or CO2 method (often promoted because they don’t kill the bees as quickly), as field trials in NSW have shown these methods can be very, very inaccurate. Use an alcohol wash and quickly and humanely euthanise ½ cup (~300 nurse bees) for the greater good of protecting not just that hive but potentially your entire apiary. Unless you are undertaking scientific research you don’t necessarily need to monitor varroa in every single hive within an apiary, as generally you can justify undertaking treatments on every hive in it as soon as you find one that has enough mites to warrant treatment.

NEVER rely on visually spotting mites on bees to determine if you may have mites, or when to treat, as that is highly inaccurate and prone to error! Seeing mites on bees generally means you already have HEAPS of them, so aim to find them with an alcohol wash on nurse bees before it ever gets to that stage!

The important thing is to keep looking regularly and act accordingly when a wash in the apiary shows that hives are experiencing mites above whatever recommended treatment threshold you follow. Then use an approved miticide treatment appropriate to your current conditions to effectively knock down the mite numbers. Don’t snooze, or you will lose your bees.

October is AFB Awareness month, so if you didn’t already do full brood checks on EVERY hive that you managed this spring then get it done sooner rather than later. Here is a great AFB guide to read Managing AFB - a field guide

Prevent any problems from getting worse by doing the right thing,

1-regularly remove the queen excluder,

2-frequently check brood (shaking bees off each frame first and then inspecting any suspicious looking cell with a match stick),

3-send in a slide sample to EMAI if needed (visible brood disease symptoms are seen) so that you find it and identify it early, EMAI Bee Disease Diagnostics Form October 2021

4-if AFB, don’t panic but do plan and prepare the hive for its final journey by removing surplus equipment and harvestable honey,

5-promptly euthanize the hive (first blocking the entrance once all bees are home after dark and then immediately adding petrol)

6-keep everything bee proofed and irradiate, sterilize or burn.

7-don’t dispose of any bee products in the general garbage

8- and most definitely DO NOT put extracted wax cappings, honey or sticky boxes etc. out so that bees can access and rob them.

9-follow the Code of Practice Code of Practice « Bee Aware

10-do this free Bee Biosecurity training https://beeaware.org.au/training/  

If this season is already looking like it will be a tough one for you to manage your hives (or you have AFB), and you would like advice from a BBO then send us an email at bee.biosecurity@dpird.nsw.gov.au

If you need to speak to someone about resilience or are looking to maybe even get out of bees, then there is a lot of helpful resources available in the National Varroa Mite Management Program in the Get Help section.

Afbawareness

USEFUL INFORMATION for beekeepershttps://www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/bees

Alcohol wash video https://youtu.be/I7YEx5vvEsY

Varroa mite video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q3tokmDwQF0

National Varroa website: https://www.varroa.org.au 

To report AFB and other notifiable bee diseases, neglected hives, bees creating a public nuisance or other bee related biosecurity issues call the Biosecurity Hotline number 1800 680 244 or report online at; https://forms.bfs.dpi.nsw.gov.au/forms/9247   

 Email your interstate health certificates to; quarantine@dpi.nsw.gov.au  

Access Biosecurity for Beekeepers BOLT training; https://beeaware.org.au/training/  

Information on Lab testing; https://www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/about-us/services/laboratory-services/sample-submission 

Biosecurity Manual for beekeepers version 1.1 Biosecurity-Manual-for-Beekeepers.pdf 

To update your beekeeper registration details and hive numbers please call (02) 6552 3000 (option 1) or email bfs.admin@dpi.nsw.gov.au 

 

Subscribe to the Bee Biosecurity Newsletters https://www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/about-us/publications/bee-biosecurity-newsletter